Showing posts with label legislation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label legislation. Show all posts

Friday, March 1, 2013

Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act


The Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act, or CISPA, is a proposed law that would give companies unprecedented power to hand your personal information from the internet, including from private communications, over to government agencies without a warrant.
When CISPA first showed up last year, we successfully defeated it together-- so we need to remind President Obama again about this dangerous threat to our personal privacy.
I just signed a petition calling on President Obama to tell Congress he intends to veto CISPA. Will you join me?
https://www.aclu.org/secure/tell-obama-veto-CISPA

Thursday, August 9, 2012

South Dakota abortion law uses false information



South Dakota wants doctors to lie to women seeking abortion by forcing doctors to inform women that having an abortion increases their risk of suicide. As one of my family members committed suicide, I find this law to be not only demeaning to a woman's choice regarding pregnancy, but to the very real problem of suicide. The law is based on faulty, misrepresented information and is merely fear-mongering on the part of the lawmakers.

That's why I signed a petition to US Supreme Court, The South Dakota State House, The South Dakota State Senate, and Governor Dennis Daugaard, which says:

"Stop using lies and fear to attempt to control women's rights and women's health issues."

Will you sign this petition? Click here:

http://signon.org/sign/south-dakota-abortion?source=s.em.cp&r_by=831852

Thanks!

Friday, May 11, 2012

Help Restore Our Civil Liberties


Friends-

We can put an end to a shocking assault on our civil liberties: Last year's National Defense Authorization Act included language that could allow the military to detain civilian suspects INDEFINITELY without charge or trial.

This year's NDAA could come up for a vote as soon as next week and we have a prime opportunity to reverse this travesty of justice.

Click here to fight back: Email your member of Congress right away:

Congressmen Adam Smith and Justin Amash will put forth an amendment to make it clear that the military does not have the power to arrest and indefinitely detain civilians without charging or trying them. Please urge your lawmakers to support their efforts and help us spread word far and wide.

Just click here to email your member of Congress right away.

Thanks!

Monday, March 5, 2012

BAD BILLBOARD BILL Guest Editorial


GOVERNOR DAUGAARD; PLEASE VETO SB-157

By Tom Katus*

The BAD BILLBOARD BILL, SB 157 has passed and will go into law.  The vote:  42 to 26.  It took 10 BILLBOARD Lobbyists, being paid tens of thousands of dollars by the BIG BILLBOARD CORPORATIONS to get this vote!  We had 0 dollars and the people to represent.  You now know what runs your State Government!

A sad day for the citizens of South Dakota, and local control of its municipalities and counties...

--Lisa Modrick
Scenic Rapid City Committee, Inc.

SD LEGISLATURE BOUGHT BY SIGN COMPANIES

-- Sign at Occupy Rapid City Rally, March 3rd.

The people of Rapid City and West River are livid about the majority of East River’s Legislators’ arrogance to override a local initiative, for which scores of us circulated petitions to have a vote on billboard control. That vote of 6,000 + was more than 2/3rds majority of the people.  I am certain that citizens of Brookings, Sioux Falls, Aberdeen, Watertown, Mitchell, and Pierre would feel similarly affronted if an initiated measure in their city, securing more than 2/3rds of the vote were overturned by the Legislature.

The undue influence of moneyed interests in the federal government has lead to widespread cynicism of the people and a Congressional approval rating of 11%.  Now the East River majority in the SD Legislature is acting equally irresponsibly and thwarting the will of the people.

We have many divisions in this State, including age, gender, race and partisanism.  However, the greatest division remains the split between East and West River.  When I served in the Senate and when I ran for State Treasurer, my major theme was to work hard to overcome these East/West Divisions and bring ALL South Dakotans together.

Last month, I lead a delegation of Legislative Fellows selected from throughout the US by our State Department to visit Nepal. We spent a week meeting with political leaders and non governmental organizations (NGOs) assisting them with their constitutional review.  Nepal is transitioning from an authoritarian centralized government to a federal democratic system. I was asked to address their National Lawyers Association, on behalf of our group, on the US Constitutional review process culminating at Independence Hall in Philadelphia in July, 1789.  I stressed that perhaps the greatest strength of our federal system is extensive LOCAL CONTROL.  A fellow delegate who is a Councilman from Concord, New Hampshire reinforced this view.  The Nepalese were very impressed with LOCAL CONTROL, and are hopeful they can institute it in their country.

Thus, it is particularly disheartening to return to SD to find that a majority of our East River Legislators has overturned the people's will.   Governor Daugaard has made some excellent strides in reaching out to ALL our people. His positive decisions on Valhalla and the Black Hills Playhouse are commendable. Vetoing this onerous legislation, would certainly reinforce his strength in the Republican Heartland of West River.  While such a stance may irritate the deep pocket sign companies, it will definitely make him more popular with 6,000+ Rapid City voters and the tourism industry. Tourism has much greater economic impact on the State than three wealthy sign companies and their 10 paid lobbyists!.

 But regardless of the politics of any such decision, a veto would be the right thing for ALL the people of South Dakota.  I am hopeful that he will once again rise above politics and do the right thing. I urge Governor Daugaard to veto SB 157.  I am confident that we would have sufficient strength in the SD House of Representatives to sustain his veto.

*********

Tom Katus served as a State Senator (2007-08), is a member of Scenic Rapid City and Occupy Rapid City. 

Friday, February 24, 2012

SOUTH DAKOTA ELECTED OFFICIALS SUPPORT GOLIATH WHILE CITIZENS SUPPORT DAVID


The following guest post is a public news release:

SOUTH DAKOTA ELECTED OFFICIALS SUPPORT GOLIATH
WHILE CITIZENS SUPPORT DAVID

Citizen Protest Against Private Foreign Companies Use of Eminent Domain


(Rapid City, SD) South Dakota elected officials including Senator Thune, Representative Noem, Governor Daugaard, and the SD Legislature continue to support TransCanada, a foreign corporation, over South Dakota landowners. Even after the Presidential permit for the proposed Keystone XL pipeline has been denied, TransCanada continues to move forward with eminent domain court proceedings against local landowners.

This Saturday, February 25, 2012 at noon, citizens of South Dakota will come together at Main Street Square in downtown Rapid City to protest TransCanada’s continued bullying of landowners and our elected officials who continue to repeat false statements about the proposed project. Citizens will speak up against their elected officials ignoring their constituents. Members of groups supporting this action include Occupy Rapid City, Dakota Rural Action, and SD Peace and Justice. We believe the Davids of our country should be represented when the Goliaths, like TransCanada, do not play fair.

While a construction project will bring short-term jobs, long-term growth for SD depends upon the health of our soil and water and the families who have spent their lives as stewards of these resources. Why would private property rights be given away to a foreign company that has not proven they can care for the land, its resources, and water?

Dakota Rural Action, a grassroots organizing non-profit, recently introduced HB 1111 into SD Legislation. This bill aims to create an even playing field for both landowners and private organizations and define a clear process for good faith negotiations where eminent domain is used as a last resort in the development of railroads and large transmission pipelines for hydrocarbons. Unfortunately, the bill failed on the House floor last week with a 35 to 35 reconsideration vote.

“According to The New York Times, the company has at least 34 eminent domain actions against landowners in Texas, and 22 in South Dakota.2 And their threats to landowners in Nebraska3 helped spark massive public opposition and a special legislative session that were key in the decision to consider a different route.” -Credo Action

South Dakota landowners have proven and earned their right to private property rights over multiple generations through their responsible stewardship. Why are we letting the Goliaths continue with condemnation proceedings on a project that offers little public benefit? 

For More Information:
Clay and Mary Ellen Uptain
Occupy Rapid City
605.341.0724

Jessica Miller
Dakota Rural Action
605.716.2200

Jim Peterson
SD Peace & Justice





Monday, February 13, 2012

24 hours to stop Keystone XL


Dear Friends,

The Senate could vote as early as tomorrow on a plan to greenlight construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline!

Despite President Obama's rejection of the Keystone XL Pipeline a few weeks ago, Republicans in Congress are once again engaging in hostage-taking, and some moderate Democrats appear to be playing along - so this bill could have enough votes to pass, and force this pipeline down our throats.

To demonstrate a massive, urgent, grassroots backlash, three dozen groups have organized a 24-hour petition drive to the Senate.

Help us get 500,000 signatures in 24 hours against Keystone XL. Click below to sign the petition:

http://act.credoaction.com/campaign/kxl_24hours/?r_by=34968-3451380-SeEQOxx&rc=confemail

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Corporate Influence


The January 23 issue of High Country News includes an article entitled Billboard corporations use money and influence to override your vote.  The Editor’s Note column on page one is headed with “An era of increasing corporate power” and you can read the editor’s comment online under the title Billboard corporations and other big industries make their own rules. 

Another example of corporate power and influence on government can be seen in the 2012 session of the South Dakota legislature a bill to undue what some people believe was a legislative mistake gets tabled in committee.  HB1098 would have restored state permitting power on uranium mines and reversed last year’s legislation. Cheryl Rowe, Lilias Jarding, and Rebecca R. Leas wrote letters to the editor of the Rapid City Journal expressing support for this year’s proposed bill.  Other opponents of last year’s legislation from the area near where the uranium mining would take place also testified before the committee.  However, one of the bill’s main sponsors decided that the bill needed to be “refined” and that she would resubmit the new bill next year.  

The following article is taken from the West River Electric February 2012 issue of the “Cooperative Connections” magazine, page 15:

It is worth it to do a little research into the reversal of the so called ban on incandescent light bulbs.  For another explanation of whether or not there is a ban on incandescent light bulbs plus lots more information on the topic look here.  One article referred to this recent US Congressional activity as a victory for the US Tea Party.  Was it in fact a victory for the Tea Party or was it an example of the effectiveness of political influence capabilities of Koch Industries?

Okay, ignore my inference to right-wing conspiracy and ask yourself some questions. 
1.  Who benefits the most from the examples of political influence listed above?
2.  Do you like looking at the local scenery that you can see through bill boards or would you prefer to just look at the scenery without the bill boards? 
3.  Is it worth the risk of polluting our drinking water in order to make it easier for Power Tech to mine for uranium in the Black Hills?
4.  If you can save money and help the whole world save energy by changing to a light bulb that is more efficient, why wouldn’t you?
5.  Who benefits if you don’t change to the more efficient light bulb?

I would like to read you answers.

Friday, December 23, 2011

60 days to reject Keystone XL


Dear Friends,

It's on. 

Congress has agreed to a two-month payroll tax and unemployment extension bill that forces a decision on the Keystone XL Pipeline, and by all accounts President Obama will sign it. 

Republicans have gotten their wish -- President Obama will have 60 days to decide on the Keystone XL Pipeline. 

And we have 60 days to make sure he rejects it. 

This is a moment to pour the pressure on. I just signed a petition asking President Obama to reject the Keystone XL Pipeline. Add your name and learn more here: 

http://act.credoaction.com/campaign/keystone_timeline/?r_by=32546-3451380-d1_aNCx&rc=paste1 

Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Four Questions for Legislators

West river legislators respond to four questions in a December 18th Rapid City Journal article.   There were few solid answers to those four questions.  Several of the legislators admitted to being unaware or their responses implied that the legislators were still campaigning or that they were inclined to provide answers that pertain to issues facing the US Congress rather than the South Dakota state legislature.  Apparently, these legislators don’t read the opinion page letters or forum page articles of the local newspapers.  They don’t seem to associate what they do in Pierre with anything that their constituents may be concerned enough about to voice a public opinion.  Perhaps the legislators were too distracted with Pierre bar fights to recall what they were told at their get together with fellow members of American Legislative Exchange Council. 

When referring to constituent concerns, the purported concerns weren’t supported by documented sources or hard numbers.  Could it be that one or two phone calls or coffee with friends constitutes the basis for the legislators’ idea of what the common concerns are for all of the voters in their respective districts?  It appears likely that these legislators will repeat whatever it was they did last year even though there is plenty of reason to believe that it will have very little to do with constituent concerns.

Thursday, February 17, 2011

We care about one another in South Dakota

Many people in the state of South Dakota are concerned with the health and welfare of their friends and neighbors. This concern is outwardly evidenced by posted signs, verbal admonitions, and governmental ordinances or laws. This does not imply that South Dakotans are the only people concerned with the health and welfare of their fellow human beings; of course not. However, as a resident of South Dakota, I am more familiar with local social conditions within my home state as opposed to the social concerns of people in the other forty-nine states. So while addressing this topic, take note that the observations expressed here may not pertain to other localities or other people.

The order or organization of this writing does not imply any specific priority or importance to the examples used, and the descriptions are subject to the personal interpretation of the writer. Consequently, the reader may assign priorities and disagree with the writer with all due freedom, the writer does not ask that anyone adopt his views, nor does the writer intend to coerce changes of opinion. The reader is fully responsible for any alteration of their own opinion after reading what is written here.

When visitors and residents drive South Dakota highways, they may notice posted road signs that show how concerned we are here for the health and welfare of others. Who hasn’t at least noticed a sign informing the viewer that they should buckle up? Of course, to avoid confusion, the buckle referred to is many times visually depicted by the figure of a person safely secured by a modern day vehicle seat belt.

Another frequently viewed road sign is intended to inform drivers that they are required to change driving lanes, if necessary, to give a wide berth to emergency vehicles stopped along side the road. A similar reminder not to litter can also be seen in numerous places around this state and not just along the roads and highways.

Operators of vehicles with dynamic braking systems may have noticed that South Dakotans are concerned with preserving peace and low noise levels in specified urban areas. We, apparently, believe that town and city dwellers need quiet places to be lulled to sleep by the normal sounds of tire engine noise.

We are also concerned with unlicensed weaponry. This type of item is not welcome in our schools, court houses, or shopping establishments. However, we like to have them close at hand everywhere else, just in case we are called upon to dispense a little self defensive or public protective justice. Rather than risk an inappropriate impression, let it be known that the author owns a permit to carry a concealed weapon, although the permit is now expired. The expiration of that card does not change the gun ownership or gun carrying views of the holder, however.

Smoking here is less socially popular than it once was. Smokers can still smoke, but restrictions to that form of consumption apply to more places than ever before, thanks to South Dakota law. Drinking of alcoholic beverages is also restricted, but we are more used to that, so people don’t resist it quite as much as we once did. We are also required to wear clothes in most places, although the definition of what constitutes cloths changes with the time of year, the municipality, and depending on which group is enjoying a rally in the state.

Recently, we have become concerned with cell phone use as it applies to people operating motor vehicles on public roads. Most of us seem to agree that texting with a cell phone while driving, is at least somewhat distracting enough that it may interfere with safe operation of the vehicle. We are concerned enough to be working on passing legislation that would ban the practice of texting while driving. It is not clear to this author if that also applies to reading text on a cell phone since it appears that the legislation will stop short of making it illegal to talk on a cell phone while driving. Dialing a phone number apparently will be okay too, so there are some things that need to be worked out with regard to cell phone use by drivers in South Dakota.

Without trying to start any argument, it is noted here that we South Dakotans are particularly interested in the health and well being of human females. Very specifically, we are concerned about their sexual activities and their procreative activities. With regard to male human beings and the same specific activities, we are concerned not so much. The level of concern we express and relating to their activities is the same for humans of the same sex who participate or would like to participate in the activities just mentioned. Our current laws and numerous proposed laws reflect this tendency toward the concern for others.

We are also concerned with health care insurance. If you have health insurance, then that is an example of part of the greatest health care system on the planet, regardless of what it costs. If you don’t have health insurance, then it probably means that you don’t deserve it and you should go live in another country. We believe this so vehemently that we have joined in a lawsuit against the federal government that has attempted to create a system that costs less, insures more people, and has the audacity to require everyone that benefits by the health system to pay into it, if they can. Obviously, that is a good plan for a national park system or a plan to improve upon public schools, but it is government intrusion into my right to go bankrupt from medical bills that exceed my ability to pay. What we South Dakotans demand in a health care reform bill is that it keep insurance and drug companies in business and able to adequately fund Congressional campaigns.

In a February 10, 2011 letter from the U.S. Congressional Representative from South Dakota she wrote that she supports a “plan that covers people with pre-existing conditions, allows those under the age of 26 to stay on their parent's policy, and permits small businesses to pool together to purchase health insurance at a lower cost. . .” It appears as though all of those things are included in the legislation she just voted to repeal, however, that is just an example of how people who have actually read the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act are trying to confuse the issue with facts. In South Dakota, we care enough about you to keep you safe from having to accept affordable health care insurance provided by the federal government. We leave this sad and arduous duty of accepting government health care insurance to people like U.S. Representative Noem.

We like education. We like it cheap. We like the reading, writing, and arithmetic, but we’re not completely sure that they are necessary beyond the eighth grade. We like education best from first through the eighth grades and require by law that much public education for our children. For the time being at least, we will continue to publicly educate our children at the expense of the taxpayers through the twelfth grade. We do not require any specific level of education or evidence of measurable intelligence for voters or our elected officials.

This list of concerns for others could go on and on, but that would not serve the purpose of the writer. This writer has an agenda. There is a concern for others that is not being properly addressed in South Dakota. Some people are unaware that it is being blown over and ignored as if it were unimportant. When are we going to wake up and realize the degree to which ear bud application is continually, albeit perhaps unintentionally, abused?

Notice if you will the markings on the ear buds that you may have in your own home. If you don’t have a set, check with a neighbor, their children may have several sets. There is a left and right ear bud, usually denoted by the letters L and R. How many times have the users of ear buds, installed those buds in their ears, without observing the associated markings and, thereby, improperly inserted the L bud in their right ear and vice versa? South Dakota Representative Hal Wick, where are you? If you aren’t too busy ensuring that all South Dakotans are adequately armed, please seek out your fellow legislator, Representative Roger Hunt, from wherever he is researching more, all important, vagina legislation. Certainly, together, the two of you can draft some meaningful legislation to purge this insidious threat to the health and well being of current and future generations of innocent South Dakotans.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Pipeline Fee Legislation, 2010

Once again a bill to impose a fee on certain pipelines carrying crude oil and to create a crude oil pipeline compensation fund that may be used in the event of a crude oil spill was up for a vote in the South Dakota Legislature this year. The same or very similar bills have been presented for consideration and passage during the previous two legislative sessions. Earlier postings relate to the previous legislation.

This year, Senator Rhoden identified that he had come full circle with his opinion on this proposed legislation. When the bill was presented to the Senate State Affairs committee and on the Senate floor, Senator Rhoden voted in favor of the bill. His stated reason for supporting the bill was to protect property owners from financial ruin resulting from the liability for an oil spill on their property.

Thank you for your votes in favor of this legislation, Senator Rhoden. Senator Rhoden also mentioned that his neighbors and others in his district were influential in changing his opinion on this legislation. Unfortunately, once again a one vote margin stopped the passage of this legislation.

This is a disappointing outcome. Hopefully, this issue will be successfully revisited again in the next legislative session. Support for new business is important to the strength of the state’s economy. However, the desire to make accommodation to attract new business to our state should not outweigh our consideration for existing business. This is especially true with regard to the oil pipeline companies. The pipelines need to cross our state in order for the pipeline companies to conduct their business and existing land owners/businesses have been required to make concessions. The full impact of these concessions was not necessarily apparent to everyone concerned when the project was first proposed to or considered by the legislature.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Something Less Than Complete Agreement

South Dakota’s governor and the state attorney general have committed South Dakota to a lawsuit that disputes the Constitutionality of the recently passed healthcare reform bill. They believe that the federal government has infringed on state’s rights with a mandate requiring individuals to purchase health insurance. Further, they imply that the federal government should not force individuals to participate in this plan without their consent. Yet the governmental mandate requiring the purchase of health insurance was previously promoted several times by Republican Party elected officials and election candidates.

I do not care to participate in this lawsuit, but apparently the Governor and the state attorney general aren’t actually concerned with this contradiction of governmental perception on personal rights infringements. It isn’t the first time they have acted in this manner. South Dakota’s majority party’s agenda has been pursued through state government with regard to the abortion issue also. Most likely, this is not a situation unique to South Dakota or to just one ruling political party.

An article from the Dakota Today blog site identified Senator Thune’s one sided view of political partisanship. Many people seem to be unable to conceive the possibility that there is than one way to view political issues and that complete agreement is not possible. Compromise appears to be the only way to achieve some level of fairness on many issues, but this concept appears lost on the ears of members of the Republican Party.

Apparently, according to Senator Thune, partisanship is something that Democrats engage in. Republicans participate in strong political opposition. When the Democrats were the minority party in Congress, they were described as partisan obstructionists when they strongly opposed Republican sponsored legislation. Interestingly, it is extremely rare that the Democrats ever act with complete unity in opposition to legislation. The Republicans appear to be able to pull that theoretically amazing unified opposition quite easily. How is it that a political party can be structure such that all of its millions of members are in complete agreement? Is it possible that all those millions are not incomplete agreement with their elected representatives?

Children often form informal groups that appear to share ideas that aren’t necessarily based on facts. Long ago, most of our ancestors were ignorant of the actual shape of the earth and the workings of the Universe. Cosmological ignorance took a long time to overcome and before it was, the incorrect concept of a flat earth was the common and unquestioned view of the majority of mankind. Isn’t it possible that simple ignorance, as well as intentional self-imposed ignorance help to unify the Republican members of Congress?

If it isn’t ignorance that results in what I view as an incorrect or an improbable degree of party unity, then what is it? Is it possible that health care reform is not actually the issue that is being resisted? Is it possible that one party political control is really the reason for the completely unified front presented by the Republican Congressional Minority?

Friday, April 17, 2009

Senator Rhoden responds to my Feb. 9, 2009 letter

Today, Senator Rhoden sent me an e-mail message asking me to speak with him on the phone regarding the questions I asked him in the letter I sent to him and published on this blog earlier. The Senator was very open and forthcoming about his reasons for voting the way he did with regard to pipeline legislation, SB171 and SB190. His main concern when SB171 was being reviewed in the Senate State Affairs Committee hearing was with the constitutionality of the bill. Upon pressing lobbyists for more information about their claim that at least one other state imposes a similar fee, Sen. Rhoden discovered that the circumstances in that state were quite different from the situation in South Dakota. The other state pipelines were intrastate systems and the pipelines in question crossing South Dakota will be inter-state transmission systems. Federal laws regarding inter-state commerce applied to the South Dakota systems that did not apply to the state lines used for comparison by the proponent lobbyists for the legislation.

My letter discounts his likely concern with the unconstitutionality of this issue compared to his apparent lack of concern for the constitutionality of other legislation. Sen. Rhoden explained that in the other case, testing the constitutionality of the legislation was the intention because of the potential for a positive outcome in the Senator's opinion. In the case of the pipeline legislation, the test stood little or no chance of resulting in a positive outcome and would therefore be nothing more than a large waste of money.

Sen. Rhoden is convinced that adequate funding is currently available to cover the costs of potential pipeline spill cleanup from two existing sources. He referenced the average estimated cost of spill cleanup based on documented historical experience numbers for pipelines in the United States.

Senator Rhoden also apologized for not getting back to me sooner. The timing of his response was not as important as the fact that he did respond and took time out to answer my questions personally, just as I had requested. The same cannot be said of all of my local district's elected officials and I thank Senator Rhoden for his time and his consideration.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

The Sioux Falls Argus Leader printed my letter to the editor (posted below) under the heading State must protect itself, March 30,2009. The following three comments were posted by Argus readers:

surviveit wrote:

Replying to ManInBlue:

good one..another like opinion
Follow the money. How much has Rounds taken from them in the last 10 years!
3/30/2009 4:05:05 PM
___________________

ManInBlue wrote:

Follow the money. How much has Rounds taken from them in the last 10 years!
3/30/2009 11:07:33 AM
___________________

StopHype wrote:

SD is so anxious to become the pollution center of the US that our government doesn't stop to think about any protections for the state or for the residents!
3/30/2009 10:34:52 AM
To: sibbyonline@hotmail.com
Subject: SB171
Date: Mon, 23 Mar 2009 22:08:46 -0600


Mr. Sibson,

We have never met, but it appears that we are both concerned about the potential consequences of a oil pipeline spill in South Dakota.

I listened to the testimony at the Senate State Affairs Committee hearing on SB171. In researching the issue, I also listened to testimony relating to SB190. A question by Senator Abdalah at the most recent hearing seemed to cut to the heart of the issue and lack of a satisfactory response left me wonder why anyone would be against this legislation.

Comments by Senator Rhoden regarding other legislation and the legislative process made me think that perhaps he could explain to me why this legislation (SB171) was killed in committee by a one vote margin. He did not respond to my letter. Consequently, I wrote to the editor of the Rapid City Journal 3-22-09, asking South Dakotans why we wouldn't want this limited, alternative protection.

Now, I'm asking you.

Sincerely,
Greg Olson
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Greg,

Thanks for your email.

The answer to your question is that the Governor is against this idea. He is afraid of scaring away business. And the Governor pretty much runs thw show in Pierre.

I am surprised Larry did not reply to you. Larry is one of the better legislators, although he is not infalliable. He pushes the line as far as he can.

There is a lot of things we need to be concerned about today. Not sure if we can put a stop to them, but I for one believe the fight must happen.

Keep in touch,
Steve

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Perhaps the general public will answer my question?

Note: Senator Rhoden chose not to respond to my letter to him (posted on this blog after a reasonable waiting period). Consequently, the following letter was submitted to the editors of several South Dakota newspapers. The Rapid City Journal published the letter on March 22, 2009.
__________

This year SB171 was proposed to provide for a fee of two cents per barrel to be levied on oil pumped through pipelines crossing South Dakota. A fund was to be created by the proceeds of the fee to be used for clean up in the event of an oil spill or some contamination emanating from the pipeline. A cap on this participating fund would be established at thirty million dollars. Similar legislation in another state requires a higher per barrel fee. For more details please refer to the actual text of the bill.
The bill was killed in the Senate State Affairs Committee by a one vote margin. The current South Dakota pipeline regulations and the testimonies by the pipeline supporters relating to pipeline spills and safety are mostly reassuring. However, there appears to be a deficiency with regard to who will pay for a clean up in the event that the pipeline company becomes insolvent or is no longer in business. This missing financial recourse is a very important consideration, especially when considering the state’s experience with specific gold mining and solid waste operations in the Black Hills area. Why wouldn’t we want this limited, alternative protection?

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

A letter to Senator Rhoden

February 9, 2009


The Honorable Larry Rhoden
The State Senate
PO Box 12
Union Center, SD 57787-0012

Dear Senator Rhoden,

Thank you for your service to South Dakota. It has been interesting to observe the 2009 session of the legislature. You are one of the few legislators that I have had an opportunity to meet in person. You have voiced in the senate and during committee hearings your particular interest in several issues that are important to me. Also, we both are residents of western South Dakota. When we met, a friend of mine had just testified at a House State Affairs committee hearing and after the meeting he introduced me to you just outside the committee chamber. During the discussion there, you told my friend, who shares many of my political views that you thought that you shared more of the same views with him on legislative issues than he might think. Consequently, it has been especially interesting to observe how you have voted on issues of interest to me, to my friend, to western South Dakota, and to the entire state.

It has been my opinion for a long time that members of political parties will vote in ways that reflect the general views of their political party. Generally this seems to be true, but on occasion, the party view does not coincide with the particular interests of the individual. You have expressed your concern for issues relating to agriculture and land owner rights. Considering how you make your living and where you come from, it is reasonable to expect that on occasion your views would differ from your own political party’s view. Also, some issues are considered nonpolitical so that party affiliation wouldn’t necessarily be an indicator of how you might vote.

With due consideration to the above statements and with no ill intention toward you in any way, your votes in Senate State Affairs Committee on SB171 were puzzling. Fortunately, with recordings of the committee hearings available, I was able to listen to the same testimony that you heard before you cast your votes relative to SB171. Compelling testimony was given by both proponents and opponents of the bill. A critical question that addresses the very heart of this issue was asked by Senator Abdallah at the initial hearing on February 13, 2009. Senator Abdallah asked the question twice; rewording it the second time for clarification and it does not appear that a complete answer was given either time. This is a paraphrase of the senator’s two questions: In the event that the pipeline company was to become financially insolvent for an unspecified reason, how is the required cleanup provided for?

One of the paid lobbyists for the pipeline company indicated that property taxes to be collected on the pipeline during the first two years of operation would be equal to the thirty million dollar fee fund outlined in SB171. How is that relevant or why should these two amounts be equated? The property taxes derived from other entities are not generally used to accumulate funds for the sole purpose of reparations.

While responding to one of your inquiries during the question portion of the hearing one of the proponents of the bill voiced a subtle concern about the makeup of the membership of the task force that was created to study the pipeline projects in South Dakota. The implication was clear that there may have been a bias that affected the reported findings of the task force.

Concern was expressed by Secretary Steve Pirner, Department of Environment and Natural Resources, for the constitutionality of charging a fee for the transportation of goods across South Dakota. Your votes on other nonrelated issues indicate that this is not necessarily a convincing enough concern to cause you to vote against legislation. Apparently, the opposite seems to be true, that in some cases you would appreciate the opportunity for the constitutionality of some legislation to be tested.

Last year SB190 started out to address the same issue of collecting a fee on barrels of oil transported by pipeline across South Dakota. The bill was passed in the senate and was presented to the House State Affairs Committee for consideration. At that hearing, the bill received a do pass recommendation from the committee, but not from you. Later in the house vote, you voted in favor of the bill. Of course, the bill was amended and no longer included the provisions for collecting a fee on products transported by pipelines. Again, audio recordings have provided the opportunity to hear what you heard during the committee hearings. What testimony from the committee meeting convinced you that this bill should not receive the do pass recommendation to the House? Further, what convinced you later to vote for the legislation during the House vote on the bill?

Since a one vote margin defeated SB171 in the Senate State Affairs Committee, I would appreciate hearing from you personally what convinced you to vote the way you did at that time. You stated in your address to the 2009 senate during the discussion before the vote on another bill of mutual interest, that it (HB1301) represented the legislative process at its best. When you and I met after the House State Affairs Committee meeting I agreed with your sentiments expressed then to that effect. Your consideration of my questions and a response would be appreciated.

Saturday, February 7, 2009

Concerns about South Dakota House Bill 1301

February 7, 2009

By Greg Olson

Most South Dakotans would agree that the intrusion of government in private life is to be avoided. Many South Dakotans would prefer to limit the size of government as well. Unfortunately, there are people of considerable monetary and personal influence that are willing to increase the size and intrusiveness of government in order to serve their own interests. It appears that legislation has been introduced over time that would help specific groups of people to avoid need for future legislative processes and/or avoid public scrutiny of the actions of governmental organizations similar to the Ellsworth Development Authority. It is difficult to view this ongoing effort to promote such legislation as something other than an effort to benefit this influential minority.
Conspiracy does not accurately explain this view of the use of influence and power with regard to government. Nor should anyone infer from this article that there is any nefarious intention associated with the coincidental minority benefit from this type of legislation. Capitalism many times allows each of us a least some opportunity to take advantage of a situation created by legislation that has as its stated intention the promotion of the public good. It is difficult to lobby against the laws that claim to provide jobs, save local tax dollars, or improve the local economy. Most promotions for this type of new legislation include these general beneficial claims. The state of the state addresses we have heard in the past usually include renditions of how well these legislative actions have worked.
Every elected official in our state has probably laid claim to being somehow personally responsible for keeping Ellsworth Air Force Base in operation. Believing these claims is normally relative to whether or not you voted for these officials instead of whether or not you or they can actually prove what they say. A large number of people in our state are convinced of the necessity of continuation of the military presence at Ellsworth AFB. It is not the intention of this article to debate the claims of elected officials or the merit of the continuation of Ellsworth AFB.
The article addresses what is disturbing about HB1301; the language of the bill is broad and somewhat ambiguous. With this type of language, what is at stake with this legislation has everything to do with limiting what it could be used for rather than desire to achieve the good it might produce now. Some of the language included in the proposed bill could be considered alarming if it is referring to actions being considered relating to someone that may be reading this article now; such as in section seven, paragraphs 27 and 28: the Authority may “Exercise such power over property controlled by the authority as is necessary or expedient for the promotion of health and safety; and do any act and execute any instrument which in the authority's judgment is necessary or convenient to the exercise of the powers granted by this Act or reasonably implied from it.” Everyone should read the entire bill.
Other language in this bill appears to circumvent the authorities of existing government bodies, such as the county commissions and city governments. Language to ensure oversight and public transparency is not obvious in the bill’s current form. There is no way for the actions of the authority to be referred to a vote of the people. The members of the Authority are appointed, not elected. As another fellow concerned citizen pointed out, if there is no intent to take advantage of this type of language now or in the future why include it?
You can be assured that minority interests that will benefit from this legislation will support it. Government officials that can use certain actions of this Authority to enhance their own images for supporting it will do so. Unfortunately, the average voter in South Dakota would like to believe in the good faith efforts of our elected officials and media reporters. As stated earlier, it is difficult to get past the claims of job creation, money saving, and economic improvement. These claims may be true, but that does not eliminate the need to keep poorly written and ambiguous legislation from becoming law.
A visit to the South Dakota Legislative Research website can be very enlightening. Political bias is non-existent at this site; it’s just the facts. The bills under consideration can be read in their entirety. Search of current and past proposed legislation can be accomplished with relative ease. For example, using the search phrase “eminent domain” can show how statutory laws have been adjusted to satisfy specific requirements. The number of references implies that our legislators have taken the time in the past to be very specific. No doubt this can be or has been a slow and frustrating process. This slow process is one of the reasons our democratic form of government is generally fair.
It can not be in the public interest to abdicate public responsibility by creating an “independent public instrumentality“ with the powers to tax, own property, and condemn property at its discretion without apparent recourse by the public other than by lawsuit. The chamber of commerce, Black Hills Vision, Ellsworth Task Force, the county commissions, two US Senators, one US Representative, the state legislature, and local city government already exist to perform some or all of the functions of this proposed Authority. Ellsworth AFB is here, the entities just listed provide a long list of accomplishments in promoting and preserving the base. What additional purpose is there for this Authority?
In article that appeared in the Feb. 7, 2009 Rapid City Journal a local Rapid City committee recommended that the state should become more involved in promoting “compatible development around the base.” Hasn’t the state been quite active in base promotion in the past? The article quoted the Mayor of Box Elder as saying, “. . . we’re in favor of the governor creating the authority as long as it’s done in friendly manner.” Is it possible to exercise eminent domain in a friendly manner?
In the RCJ article the authority is referred to as “an important mechanism to help deal with growth.” This analogy implies that the authority is another tool to be used to accomplish a task. Tools generally are used to perform specific purposes. The tools already exist to tax, create easements, condemn property, acquire property, zone, and several other powers either listed or implied in this new legislation. What not so obvious new tool feature does this legislation provide?